Sleeve Notes
Sleeve Notes1972
Who Is He and What Is He to You

Who Is He and What Is He to You

Bill Withers · 1972
Recording

Recorded in Los Angeles at Record Plant during the Still Bill sessions, with Bill Withers working alongside the Watts 103rd Street Rhythm Band core of Ray Jackson, Benorce Blackmon, Melvin Dunlap, and James Gadson. Ray Jackson handled the horn and string arrangements, and Bob Hughes and Phil Schier were the engineers. Released on Still Bill in 1972, the track stood out for its tense, understated groove and its sharply drawn jealousy narrative. It helped define the album’s reputation as a stripped-down, emotionally direct classic of 1970s R&B. The song has remained one of Withers’ best-known album tracks and has been repeatedly covered, including versions by Creative Source and Meshell Ndegeocello. Its lyrical economy and slinking groove have kept it in circulation as a deep-catalog favorite.

ArtistBill Withers
Year1972
GenreDisco
StudioRecord Plant, Los Angeles
LabelSussex
ProducersBill Withers · Ray Jackson · Benorce Blackmon · Melvin Dunlap · James Gadson
How curators tag this
Disco50%
Soul50%
Sound check
Same ArtistFig. A
Better Days
Bill Withers · 1971
Better Off Dead
Bill Withers · 1971
Documentary
Bill Withers · 1971
Everybody’s Talkin’
Bill Withers · 1971
Grandma’s Hands
Bill Withers · 1971
SamplesFig. B
Who Is She (And What Is She to You)
Gladys Knight & the Pips · 1973 · sampled-by
Who Is He And What Is He To You
Creative Source · 1974 · sampled-by
Who Is He and What Is He to You
Meshell Ndegeocello · 1996 · sampled-by
Who Is He (And What Is He To You)
Tower of Power · 2009 · sampled-by
Year · 1972Fig. C
Funky Worm
Ohio Players · 1972
Just a Dream
Slim Smith · 1972
Think
Lyn Collins · 1972
The Harder They Come
Jimmy Cliff · 1972
Louie Louie
Toots & The Maytals · 1972
Same GenreFig. D
The Last Mile Of The Way
Sam Cooke · 1970
Motivation
Atmosfear · 1981
Let's Go All The Way
Brenda & the Tabulations · 1977
It Should Have Been Me
Yvonne Fair · 1975
Dance Freak
Chain Reaction · 1980
Artist · Bill WithersIn the Sleeve Notes
1970s
1971Ain't No Sunshine
1971Harlem
1972Who Is He and What Is He to YouYou are here
1977Lovely Day
Undated
—Lean on Me
END / SLEEVE NOTESMIXUDG © 2026